Bros. Bro-tank. Brah. Brotastic. Bromance. Brohemia. The
rise of “bro” culture saddens me, not least because so much of the “bro”
persona is a thinly veiled attempt to hide the awkwardness of male friendship,
particularly among young men. One of the strongest qualities of Eric
Gansworth’s If I Ever Get Out of Here
is that it so evocatively presents that very awkwardness, as the narrator Lewis
Blake and the newly arrived George Haddonfield bond over music, girls, bullies,
family, and Wacky Packages (yes, the book is set in the 1970s, and I had
forgotten all about Wacky Packages until reading If I Ever Get Out of Here).
Such honest male friendships are all too rare in young adult
literature. Certainly many books
intended for male readers are published (I know the author Maureen Johnson says
books should not have a gender, and I understand and support her
argument, but until we improve our culture I still need to find books that will
appeal to my current male students), and I read many of them trying to find titles
that will engage my more reluctant male readers.
Diverse perspectives are another rarity in young adult
literature. The popularity of Sherman Alexie’s The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian notwithstanding, Native
voices and Native characters are hard to find, and ignorance of Native life
outside of the history textbooks (which themselves often do a poor job of
presenting Native history) remains pervasive, at least among my students in the
Midwest. If I Ever Get Out of Here helps
change that.
The book tells the story of Lewis, a brainy Native kid from
the reservation attending classes with the white kids at the local school. He
is socially isolated, stuck between two worlds: the traditional ways of his
tribe, and the ways of the white kids at his school. But when George's family
moves to the military base nearby, Lewis makes his first real friend his own
age, and makes his first foray into the world of the white culture.
The Cybils-nominated If I Ever Get Out of
Here does a wonderful job of showing the awkward friendship between
two teenage guys, a friendship that transcends race and class. George's father
is an officer, so the family is fairly well off. Lewis's father has no part in
his life, and Lewis is ashamed of his home and the cleaning jobs his mother is
forced to take. Their friendship grows, and then grows strained as George has
his first girlfriend and Lewis must deal with severe bullying.
I taught mostly Native students when I worked in New Mexico,
and although Lewis grows up on a reservation in upstate New York (as did the
author), many of the cultural struggles of his tribe reminded me of what I
learned from my students, most of whom faced the same tough question as Lewis:
"In the same way, I thought, I wanted to be just me,
Lewis Blake, not "Indian Lewis" like I was at school. I didn't have
any objections to being known as an Indian, but couldn't I have my own life as
just me? Or like McCartney, was I stuck being expected to play
the songs of my first band for the rest of my life? Could you play both, or
were you required to make a choice?" (159)
If I Ever Get Out of
Here was an excellent novel, and it deserves wider readership. Highly
recommended.
No comments :
Post a Comment